Difference between revisions of "Result range"
m |
(domain -> range) |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
[[Category:Glossary term]] | [[Category:Glossary term]] | ||
<section begin=glossary /> | <section begin=glossary /> | ||
| − | :The ''' | + | :The '''result range of a variable''' contains all possible values that the result of the variable may get with probability P>0. The result range is restricted by logical (the number of actual individuals must be an integer), rational (concentration cannot be negative or above 1000 g/kg), and observational ([[:en:TCDD|TCDD]] concentration in humans has never been observed to be above 144000 ng/kg fat) statements. The utility of result range comes from the dependencies to other variables. Child variables are probability distributions conditional on their parents. If the result range of the parents is defined and more or less unchanged, it facilitates the definition process of the children. The conditional probability distribution of a child is only defined for the parent values within its result range. |
<section end=glossary /> | <section end=glossary /> | ||
| − | Should ' | + | Should 'Result range' be a sub-attribute of 'Definition' in a variable? Alternative solution: it is discussed under 'Data', because in practice, the result range is based on Data. Third alternative: it is put under 'Result', maybe as a sub-attribute; this is not a good idea, because the result range has implications on e.g. 'Formula', and it is not good if the result affects Definition. |
| − | :→ Because clear understanding does not yet exist, the attribute structure is not changed, and the | + | :→ Because clear understanding does not yet exist, the attribute structure is not changed, and the result range is described under 'Data'. {{reslink|Renaming needed?}} |
==Scope== | ==Scope== | ||
| − | How can a plausible | + | How can a plausible result range for a variable be found? What are the criteria for inclusion or exclusion of a particular value or range? |
==Definition== | ==Definition== | ||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
===Rationale=== | ===Rationale=== | ||
| − | In expert judgement, it is a common practice to define the | + | In expert judgement, it is a common practice to define the result range by calculating the difference between the fractiles 0.05 and 0.95, extend that by k % (k is often 10 % or found by optimising), and subtract it from and add it to the fractiles 0.05 and 0.95, respectively. |
| − | In [[open assessment]], all values are included in the | + | In [[open assessment]], all values are included in the result range by default. A suggested procedure is to exclude any range X that passes a critical [[argumentation]] about the exclusion. The argumentation has a statement of the following form: "It is impossible that the result of the variable may be within range X." If the statement is accepted, X is excluded from the result range. {{reslink|Should inclusion or exclusion be the default?}} |
==Procedure== | ==Procedure== | ||
| − | All values are included in the | + | All values are included in the result range by default. Any range X that passes a critical [[argumentation]] about the exclusion will be excluded. The argumentation has a statement of the following form: "It is impossible that the result of the variable may be within range X." If the statement is accepted, X is excluded from the result range. |
==See also== | ==See also== | ||
* [[Variable]] | * [[Variable]] | ||
Latest revision as of 18:29, 23 May 2010
This page is a method.
The page identifier is Op_en2530 |
|---|
| Moderator:Nobody (see all) Click here to sign up. |
|
Give your opinion to the peer rating of the content of this page. |
| Upload data
|
<section begin=glossary />
- The result range of a variable contains all possible values that the result of the variable may get with probability P>0. The result range is restricted by logical (the number of actual individuals must be an integer), rational (concentration cannot be negative or above 1000 g/kg), and observational (TCDD concentration in humans has never been observed to be above 144000 ng/kg fat) statements. The utility of result range comes from the dependencies to other variables. Child variables are probability distributions conditional on their parents. If the result range of the parents is defined and more or less unchanged, it facilitates the definition process of the children. The conditional probability distribution of a child is only defined for the parent values within its result range.
<section end=glossary />
Should 'Result range' be a sub-attribute of 'Definition' in a variable? Alternative solution: it is discussed under 'Data', because in practice, the result range is based on Data. Third alternative: it is put under 'Result', maybe as a sub-attribute; this is not a good idea, because the result range has implications on e.g. 'Formula', and it is not good if the result affects Definition.
- → Because clear understanding does not yet exist, the attribute structure is not changed, and the result range is described under 'Data'. R↻
Scope
How can a plausible result range for a variable be found? What are the criteria for inclusion or exclusion of a particular value or range?
Definition
Rationale
In expert judgement, it is a common practice to define the result range by calculating the difference between the fractiles 0.05 and 0.95, extend that by k % (k is often 10 % or found by optimising), and subtract it from and add it to the fractiles 0.05 and 0.95, respectively.
In open assessment, all values are included in the result range by default. A suggested procedure is to exclude any range X that passes a critical argumentation about the exclusion. The argumentation has a statement of the following form: "It is impossible that the result of the variable may be within range X." If the statement is accepted, X is excluded from the result range. R↻
Procedure
All values are included in the result range by default. Any range X that passes a critical argumentation about the exclusion will be excluded. The argumentation has a statement of the following form: "It is impossible that the result of the variable may be within range X." If the statement is accepted, X is excluded from the result range.
