Difference between revisions of "Talk:Nugget"
(Parameters corrected) |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{discussion | {{discussion | ||
| − | | | + | |Statements= Name of this entity should be statement (or claim, or something else) instead of nugget |
| − | |Resolution= | + | |Resolution= |
|Argumentation = | |Argumentation = | ||
{{defend|1| While the word ''nugget'' has the advantange of being easy to remember, it does not adequately describe the two key aspects of the concept: 1) a piece of information that '''will remain in its original form''', 2) a piece of information that has '''distinguished authors'''. There are words that more aptly describe these features: e.g. claim, statement. The word '''statement''' is more self-explanatory and is therefore suggested instead of ''nugget''.|[[User:Erkki Kuusisto|Erkki Kuusisto]]}} | {{defend|1| While the word ''nugget'' has the advantange of being easy to remember, it does not adequately describe the two key aspects of the concept: 1) a piece of information that '''will remain in its original form''', 2) a piece of information that has '''distinguished authors'''. There are words that more aptly describe these features: e.g. claim, statement. The word '''statement''' is more self-explanatory and is therefore suggested instead of ''nugget''.|[[User:Erkki Kuusisto|Erkki Kuusisto]]}} | ||
Latest revision as of 12:51, 16 November 2009
Should we call this entity a "statement" (rather than nugget)
| Statements: Name of this entity should be statement (or claim, or something else) instead of nugget
Resolution: Resolution not yet found. (A stable resolution, when found, should be updated to the main page.) |
| Argumentation:
←1: While the word nugget has the advantange of being easy to remember, it does not adequately describe the two key aspects of the concept: 1) a piece of information that will remain in its original form, 2) a piece of information that has distinguished authors. There are words that more aptly describe these features: e.g. claim, statement. The word statement is more self-explanatory and is therefore suggested instead of nugget. Erkki Kuusisto
←3: Nugget, despite being short, simple and easy to remember, has not gained much support from the current active/semi-active open assessment community. Perhaps another name, e.g. claim, could do better in describing this entity. --Mikko Pohjola 07:30, 3 February 2009 (EET)
|
