Difference between revisions of "Fifteen-unit rule for rounding numerical results"
m |
(justification added) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
==Scope== | ==Scope== | ||
| − | When presenting the final results of a study, what is | + | When presenting the final results of a study, what is a scientifically sound method for rounding numerical results of the form "average value ± probable uncertainty"? |
==Definition== | ==Definition== | ||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
Thus, before publishing, a systematic method for rounding those results to a justifiable and meaningful precision is needed, in order to avoid a misconception of excessively (in)accurate results. | Thus, before publishing, a systematic method for rounding those results to a justifiable and meaningful precision is needed, in order to avoid a misconception of excessively (in)accurate results. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The 15-unit rule is a practical method (used in e.g. the teaching of university-level physics and engineering) that ensures that neither the average value nor the probable uncertainty will be expressed with a meaninglessly high precision. | ||
==Result== | ==Result== | ||
Revision as of 09:25, 9 August 2011
This page is a method.
The page identifier is Op_en5327 |
|---|
| Moderator:Erkki Kuusisto (see all) |
|
Give your opinion to the peer rating of the content of this page. |
| Upload data
|
Scope
When presenting the final results of a study, what is a scientifically sound method for rounding numerical results of the form "average value ± probable uncertainty"?
Definition
Usually, from scientific studies (whether based on physical measurements or mathematical modelling), numerical results are obtained that consist of an average value or a best estimate (e.g. 4.5678 meters) and a measure of the probable uncertainty (e.g. ±0.2345 meters). However, as raw figures, either or both of these may be too precise (i.e. contain more digits than is justifiable or meaningful).
Thus, before publishing, a systematic method for rounding those results to a justifiable and meaningful precision is needed, in order to avoid a misconception of excessively (in)accurate results.
The 15-unit rule is a practical method (used in e.g. the teaching of university-level physics and engineering) that ensures that neither the average value nor the probable uncertainty will be expressed with a meaninglessly high precision.
Result
The 15-unit rule says that:
- in the average value, the uncertainty of the least significant digit (LSD) must not exceed 15 units,
- the probable uncertainty must not exceed 15 units (where one unit pertains to the LSD of the average value)
- the probable uncertainty is always rounded upwards.
Please see the following examples:
- (1062 ± 41) meters is incorrect, because the LSD of the average value (2) is associated with an uncertainty of 41 units (and the uncertainty is expressed using a precision of 41 units)
- (1060 ± 50) meters is correct, because the LSD of the average value (6) is now associated with an uncertainty of 5 units only (and the uncertainty is expressed using a precision of 5 units)
- - Note that the original uncertainty (41) has been rounded upwards (to 50).
- (0.8765 ± 0.0132) kg is incorrect, because the LSD of the average value (5) is associated with an uncertainty of 132 units (and the uncertainty is expressed using a precision of 132 units)
- (0.876 ± 0.014) kg is correct, because the LSD of the average value (6) is now associated with an uncertainty of 14 units only (and the uncertainty is expressed using a precision of 14 units)
- - Note that the original uncertainty (0.0132) has been rounded upwards (to 0.014).
